Hello my E-Buddies!
I read somewhere in our E-moderating notes the possibility of a Cyberspace War? I came across some postings, which I consider to fit that category (or at least dangerously close!!). So I thought this would provide us with a good opportunity to practise our E-moderating skills.
The exercise was a seemingly innocent topic: seeking our views on a statement released by an Asian leader** and the impact of that statement on the operation of Australian companies in South East Asia. (The Leader** commented on his opposition to the International Declaration on Human Rights as he believes the Declaration does not reflect cultural life and values in South East Asia)
One of the students (Lucy White: fictitious name) responded with “evidences”++ (articles on websites etc) on how the leader has allegedly abused human rights in his country. [Personally, I would say it is rather disconcerting for someone from that country to read all these “evidences”.] She concluded with a summary of the views from both the critics and supporters of the Declaration, indicating that the bottom line is about political power and not cultural values as claimed.
The response from another student (Mohammad Abdullah: fictitious name) was swift. (I have paraphrased the reply (while trying to keep the tone of the email).
“Your response is a repeat of the much publicised stories from the usual suspects. Bogus opportunists and Amnesty International. What is AI doing when it comes to defending the rights of people being held in cages for two years without charges?? You spoke of people from that Asian country writing to Tony Blair, the same person who has a problem telling the truth? The last time I checked, tony was the PM for UK, what has the problems of that Asian country got to do with him????? Leader** may have some inadequacies, but he did an excellent job for his country and people. Good on you Leader** and long live the dream!”
Lucy responded with what AI is doing at G Bay etc. and finished with a query: “...... and what false premise are you referring to?”
Scenario: You are the Emoderator of this course. The quick responses between the two did not allow you the opportunity to intervene in between the postings.
Task: What would you do?
I would be very interested to hear from you all….back to the good old days Folks!
Looking forward
Jenny